|
MARCH 31
Reds need cash to
compete
Part two of the ECHO Sport series examining the
financial state of Liverpool Football Club season 2004/05
By David Prentice - Liverpool Echo
It has been a long, often turbulent year for Liverpool Football Club
with as much drama happening off the pitch as there has been on it.
But today the ECHO reveals that it could yet end in smiles for everyone
at Anfield, with the hopes of securing major new investment far from
dead.
Despite the first anniversary of the hunt for new backers arriving last
week, the club has by no means given up hope of doing a deal which could
see millions of pounds in new money pumped into Anfield.
There are at least two major parties talking to the club about a
potential investment deal. While agreement is some way off and by no
means certain to happen, there could yet be a positive announcement to
silence the doubters and ease concerns of supporters.
The parties are said to be 'serious players of both wealth and repute'
and direct dialogue is known to be ongoing.
If investment comes from either it will almost certainly herald a new
era at Anfield, with chairman David Moores likely to take on a lesser
role or possibly moving out completely after 15 years in ultimate
control.
If no deal ensues, senior figures at Anfield are happy the club will not
lurch into a sudden financial crisis but will continue on under Moores
and chief executive Rick Parry and consider other strategies for the
immediate future.
The club's position would be reviewed some time during the close
season to find ways of adding to the the money already given to Benitez
to build the team he wants.
The club and Benitez remain adamant it wants to build that side around
skipper Steven Gerrard despite persisitent rumours about his future -
many clearly designed to try and lure him away from Anfield.
His revelation in the ECHO last week that he has not given promises to
other clubs gave massive reassurance to fans who worship their
world-class skipper.
Former Redrow tycoon Steve Morgan is not one of the two parties
currently in discussions with Liverpool.
Morgan came close to doing a deal to take over at Anfield last year
but withdrew his final offer after being rebuffed in December.
He had altered the terms of his bid following the due diligence process
- a series of detailed financial checks carried out prior to any
investment - claiming more money than he expected would be needed from
him to pay for the rising costs of the stadium.
His pull-out followed a second lively annual meeting in December at
which Morgan again publicly called upon the Anfield board and Moores to
allow him in.
Parry said at December's AGM - the second within a year at which
Liverpool's off field ownership issues were laid bare - that the
investment issue needed to be brought to a conclusion soon.
So far though, there has been no announcement about new backers and the
club is still working behind the scenes and declining to comment until
it feels the time is right.
The pressing priority for Liverpool, though, is to see an end to the
delay over grant funding for its planned new stadium in Stanley Park.
The Anfield board are baffled and increasingly concerned at delays in
the North West Development Agency, the body which distributes government
funding for redevelopment, awarding it an £11m grant to regenerate the
park plus surrounding areas in Anfield.
NWDA chairman Bryan Gray is insisting the grant won't be given unless a
groundshare plan is resurrected.
Walton MP Peter Kilfoyle has led a chorus of complaints over the NWDA
man's demands, which fly in the face of wishes of fans from both
Goodison and Anfield.
Sports Minister Richard Caborn has already declared ground-sharing a
dead issue and Kilfoyle has insisted Liverpool are being held to ransom
after years of careful planning and consultation.
The club is currently facing a bill of £750k a month for the delays,
with construction costs rising at one per cent a month - thanks in part
to the new found confidence in Liverpool and the Capital of Culture
award making it a more attractive propositon to developers.
Liverpool are understandably anxious for the grant to be given and feel
they are being unfairly treated - given neighbours Everton were offered
major public funding several years ago with their plans to build a new
home at Kings Dock, plans which ultimately came to nothing.
But they will only comment publicly and in detail once discussions with
the two parties have reached a conclusion.
And there may be nothing of substance said publicly until the season has
ended - despite all the speculation, the bids, the claims and the
rumours which have surrounded Liverpool for the past 12 months.
MARCH 30
Reds still
waiting for right time to cash in
Part one of a special two part series examining the
financial state of Liverpool Football Club
By David Prentice - Liverpool Echo
On the football pitch, Liverpool Football Club took a significant
step towards claiming a £20m Champions League cash prize last week, with
a famous derby triumph.
Off it, despite tireless efforts, the Reds are seemingly no closer to
announcing an equally important investment.
Exactly a year prior to the date of the Anfield derby triumph, Liverpool
hired a firm of financial advisors to flush out potential investors in
the club.
So far the flushing process has proved more effective than the
depositing.
Last spring directors spent hours in meaningful, but ultimately
fruitless, talks with Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra.
Advances from Hollywood based film producer Mike Jefferies and his L4
group were politely but firmly rebuffed, while building contractor and
lifelong Reds fan Steve Morgan has presented investment packages on four
separate occasions - and been told each time his offers were not good
enough.
And during that timescale the club has seen a £3.6m profit nosedive into
a £21.9m loss.
Much of that dramatic turn-around came on the back of a year without
Champions League football, and the cost of parting company with the
previous managerial team.
A march to the quarter-finals of the Champions League this season - and
possibly beyond - is certain to turn that figure around.
But by how much is unclear, and Liverpool still have four points to make
up on Everton. Liverpool Football Club still needs significant
investment - and urgently..
The proposed new stadium has already soared from a projected cost of
£80m, when it was first presented to a Liverpool AGM in 2003, to £115m
in December 2004. Now that figure has swelled again, to more than £120m.
The longer the delays, the greater the financial burden on the club.
And that is just off the pitch. On it, since they claimed the first
league title of the 1990s, the Reds have gathered an impressive
collection of knockout trophies - the FA Cup twice, the UEFA Cup and the
League Cup three times - but the prize which the club most covets, once
claimed as its raison d'etre, has consistently eluded them.
They ended the previous season 30 points behind champions Arsenal.
Since then they have secured the services of one of the brightest, most
respected managers in European football - but still look likely to end
this current campaign a similar distance behind the latest champions
elect, Chelsea.
Clearly even more funds are still required to enable Benitez to fashion
his own squad - and Liverpool do not want to even countenance the sale
of Steven Gerrard to finance that rebuilding.
Sponsorship opportunities pose few problems.
Carslberg, the club's official sponsors, are currently in the final year
of their contract - but negotiations are ongoing about the association
continuing.
Carlsberg have been club sponsors now since 1992, enjoying one of the
longest and most high profile part-nerships in the game.
Outside investment seems the only likely source of significant further
income, but the Reds seem adamant that they will not act until they are
convinced they have secured the right package.
"The board of Liverpool FC confirms it is continuing discussions with a
number of parties regarding a potential investment of new funds into the
club," said chief executive Rick Parry three weeks ago when the club was
forced by a technicality to make a formal statement to the Stock
Exchange that it was not following up L4's advances.
"We are looking for the right investment. A lot of effort is going
into that - and when the process has been completed we will announce
something."
Liverpool clearly still remain a sought after investment opportunity.
Chakrapot Penkai, spokesman for the Thai Prime Minister said last
spring: "Why does the Prime Minister want to invest in Liverpool?
Because it is the era of the brand name. With a brand name you can do
many things.
"Liverpool's name is a world class name - people attach their fantasies,
their liking for sports, their enhancement in life, their
self-development, along with this kind of team."
But while a legion of Liverpudlians waits expectantly, the clock is
ticking.
MARCH 30
Rebuffed fan Morgan waits in the wings
Liverpool Echo
To date, Steve Morgan has made four separate offers to invest in
Liverpool Football Club.
The most public bid, last May, suffered the same fate as the others,
tossed out and rejected as "unattractive."
A club statement said: "The Bridg-mere proposal of £1.750 per share
implies a current value of £61m for the entire club, which is a
substantial dis-count to the value placed on the club by the board."
So what is Liverpool worth? And if Liverpool is worth more than £61m, is
there anybody else out there willing to pay the asking price?
Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra initially proposed £60m for just
a 30 per cent stake in Liverpool - but few details were made public.
When Steve Morgan presented his plans he did so in a carefully detailed
- and public - submission.
The first step of Morgan's proposal was to have a 10 for 1 share split,
which meant Liverpool's current 35,000 share base would become 350,000.
David Moores would see his shares rise from 17,850 to 178,500 (still a
51 per cent controlling interest), Granada would have 34,650 (9.9 per
cent) and Steve Morgan 17,850 (5.1 per cent).
Morgan would then underwrite a one-for-one rights share issue with each
share valued at £175, generating £61m.
If David Moores decided not to buy up any new shares, his holding would
be slashed to 25.5 per cent, while Morgan could own a minimum of 214,200
shares (30.6 per cent) at a cost of £34.4m, or a maximum of 367,850
(52.5 per cent) at a cost of £61.3m.
In other words, he would control the club.
To prevent this happening, David Moores would probably have to invest
between £12m and £20m to remain as majority shareholder.
His personal wealth is not known, but such an outlay would appear to be
well within his means.
The Moores family's Littlewoods empire was sold to the Barclay twins for
£35.9m and the Moores family is believed to be worth £1,255m in total.
Steve Morgan has made his fortune from Redrow Homes, with The Times Rich
List placing him at 105 in Britain with an estimated fortune of £312m.
If Morgan is to ever succeed, he may have to improve his offer
significantly. But he has previously insisted his price is a fair one -
and stressed his method of moving in mirrors that employed by Moores 14
years ago.
Malcolm Glazer, by comparison, is expected to formally offer £3.00 per
share to buy a controlling interest in Manchester United.
That, offer, however, is way in excess of what most experts believe the
club to be worth. Even generous analysts value United at only 240p per
share. Shares closed last Friday at 2661/2p.
MARCH 8
L4 Group out of
picture
Sporting Life
Liverpool have dismissed any chance of American-based L4 Group
investing in the club but remain determined to find new funds from
elsewhere.
In an announcement via the Stock Exchange, the Anfield club ruled out a
cash injection from the consortium put together by two US-based
entertainment executives and thought to have the backing of the Kraft
family - owners of the New England Patriots (NFL) and the New England
Revolution soccer franchises.
"The board of Liverpool FC confirms it is continuing discussions with a
number of parties regarding a potential investment of new funds into the
club," said the statement.
"The club has discontinued discussions with the L4 Group. A further
announcement will be made when appropriate."
Just three months ago, Liverpool denied they were in negotiations with
L4. Conversations have obviously taken place since then, although the
outcome appears to have been unsatisfactory.
Tuesday's statement reflects the comments of chief executive Rick Parry,
who yesterday admitted Liverpool were still in talks with would-be
investors and admitted his club's third-largest shareholder Steve Morgan
is still in the frame after seeing previous bids rejected.
"We are looking for the right investment. A lot of effort is going into
that - and when the process has been completed we will then announce
something," he said.
Liverpool badly need extra funds as they seek to bankroll a new stadium
in Stanley Park, the cost of which has spiralled, and significant squad
rebuilding under manager Rafael Benitez.
The Reds have fallen behind their traditional rivals on the pitch - and
Benitez, who arrived at Anfield last summer, is planning a major
overhaul of his squad in the close season in an attempt to close the gap
on Chelsea, Manchester United and Arsenal.
FEBRUARY 8
Moores
ready to go the extra mile
Sporting Life
Liverpool chairman David Moores could dip into his own pocket to fund
his club's transfers at the end of the season.
Despite reports over the last year of consortiums planning to invest at
Anfield, no deal has been agreed to bring cash to the Barclays
Premiership club.
Fernando Morientes was brought to the club from Real Madrid for
£6.3million during the transfer window, but Liverpool's financial future
remains uncertain.
With skipper Steven Gerrard understood to be a target for current
leaders Chelsea, building a strong squad is seen as the key to keeping
the 24-year-old on Merseyside.
"He (Moores) will do whatever it takes to move it forward, even if it
affects his own interests. He cares more about this club than about
himself," said chief executive Rick Parry.
Potential investment from the Thai Government or American investors has
not materialised, while local businessman Steve Morgan has failed in his
attempt to take control of the club.
Morgan withdrew his offer of a £70million cash injection in December,
with his lawyer insisting the lifelong Reds fan had "lost patience" with
the club's current board over their failure to strike a deal.
With reports of a move away from Liverpool, Parry admitted on Monday the
club would not keep Gerrard "against his will" if a big bid arrived.
"It is a frustration that we have not come up with the investment, but
life is not like that," Parry added on official website
www.liverpoolfc.tv
"We have got through this season tolerably - we've invested £43million
in the team, so we've not tightened the purse strings too much.
"Apart from maybe Chelsea, by anyone else's standards that's a
reasonable investment.
"The chairman is quite positive at the moment because he's quite pleased
with how Rafa's been performing, 2004 was a difficult year from his
point of view but there is no better chairman in the world of football.
No manager could have greater backing."
"It was particularly difficult in the summer with Gerard (Houllier)
going and the uncertainty over Stevie (Gerrard). But having got Rafa
(Benitez) on board and seeing some signs of progress he's happier, but
still extremely keen to find the right investment."
FEBRUARY 7
Parry
relishes Anfield challenge
BBC Sport reflects on the future for Liverpool after our exclusive
interview with chief executive Rick Parry.
By Phil McNulty, Chief football writer - BBC Sport Online
Rick Parry's in-tray reflects his status as the man charged with one
of football's biggest challenges.
Chief executive Parry is the man at the helm as Liverpool reach the most
crucial point in their recent history.
Parry has to deliver a new 60,000-seat stadium in Stanley Park by 2007
amid claims of costs spiralling above £120m.
He is also searching for an investment package of a size and stature
that will restore Liverpool to their place at European football's top
table.
But it is a challenge that appears to sit easily with Parry, who has
forged a reputation as one of football's most respected administrators
since his days at the fledgling Premier League.
Liverpool have not won the championship since 1990, a fact that causes
deep discomfort inside Anfield as they attempt to muscle in on the top
three of Chelsea, Manchester United and Arsenal.
Throw in the small matter of warding off every top club in world
football as they eye captain Steven Gerrard, and you can see Parry is a
man with a lot on his plate.
But in the comfort of a conference room deep inside Liverpool's
heartbeat - The Kop end - Parry spoke to us with brutal honesty about
the crucial months ahead.
He only dodged one question - when asked to reveal the name of the
mystery investor currently courting Liverpool, a polite smile deflected
the inquiry.
But to his credit, he met everything else head on in measured tones that
underscore the belief that Liverpool still mean business.
By business he means becoming title challengers again, and locking the
pieces together that will help return the trophy to Liverpool is Parry's
mission.
Parry has already successfully put one of those planks in place in the
form of new manager Rafael Benitez.
And his enthusiasm for the Spaniard's personality and methods is an
indication of his clear feeling that he has struck gold.
Benitez's early work has given Parry renewed optimism about the years
ahead.
But it remains a massive task at a club with a unique history and
expectations.
This will not come as news to Parry, a lifelong Liverpool supporter, but
his quiet determination suggests he is no mood to be found wanting...
WHAT PARRY SAID ABOUT GERRARD
Captain Gerrard is central to Liverpool's plans and Parry's insistence
that all offers will be refused is a firm statement of intent.
As ever, the player will have the final say, and Parry acknowledges
that, but he is determined to provide the framework and environment for
Liverpool and Gerrard to flourish.
WHAT PARRY SAID ABOUT NEW INVESTMENT
In terms of the search for new investment, Hawkpoint were appointed as
advisors to flush out interest in March 2004.
Thailand Prime Minister Thaksin Shiniwatra came and went, while the most
serious statement of intent came from tycoon and lifelong fan Steve
Morgan.
Morgan had a succession of bids rejected, having come close in the
summer only for talks to break down over potential costs for the new
stadium.
BBC Sport understands Morgan is still ready and willing to invest in
Liverpool, and Parry has kept the door ajar despite currently seeking
investment elsewhere.
Morgan, however, has had no formal contact with Liverpool or their
advisors since last December, blaming indecision at board level as he
publicly withdrew his £70m offer.
He was also convinced his interest was being used to lure in others, so
any new approach would now have to come from Liverpool. Morgan will
certainly not be making another call.
So speculation continues about the new benefactor, with trails leading
to the Middle East and America, but all met with an understandable veil
of secrecy from Anfield.
WHAT PARRY SAID ABOUT THE NEW STADIUM
Parry meanwhile sees the new ground as crucial to Liverpool's future,
but is refusing to become emotionally attached to the idea.
He is determined the ground will only be built on an affordable basis
and will not make future Liverpool management hostages to the new
stadium.
Parry will pull back the moment the figures do not stack up, but there
has been a vital new development in North London that has re-shaped
Liverpool's thinking.
Liverpool have publicly refused to entertain the idea of stadium
sponsorship and potential naming rights - but the realism of Arsenal's
stunning £100m deal for their new Emirates Stadium at Ashburton has
changed the landscape.
Parry labelled the deal "an eye-opener" and admits Liverpool would be
missing a trick not to explore the possibilities.
He knows some traditionalist Liverpool fans will reel at any attempt to
call the new stadium anything other than just 'Anfield', but the maths
of modern-day football decree that multi-millions for stadium and team
could ease the pain.
|