agent quiet on exit reports
Rafael Benitez's agent on Wednesday night refused
to discuss reports the Spaniard is set to leave Liverpool.
Benitez experienced a dismal 2009/10 season as his team finished
only seventh in the Premier League and suffered early exits from the
Champions League, FA Cup and Carling Cup.
According to several reports, Liverpool have made Benitez an offer
to walk away from the club, however there has been no official
Agent Manuel Garcia Quilon said: "We don't know anything more than
what's being said.
"We're not saying anything."
Benitez, 50, signed a five-year contract in March 2009.
He joined Liverpool in 2004 after a successful spell with Valencia
and led the club to Champions League victory in his first season,
however the Premier League title has been elusive and Benitez's team
were unable to build on a second-placed finish in the 2008/09
The former Valencia manager has recently been linked with the
vacancy at Inter Milan, following Jose Mourinho's move to Real
Benitez on verge of Liverpool exit
BBC Sport Online
Liverpool manager Rafael Benitez is on the verge
of leaving the club, BBC Sport understands.
Benitez will be offered a multi-million pound severance deal to quit
Anfield and could depart by the weekend.
The Spaniard, 50, signed a five-year contract in March 2009, but
failed to deliver success last season as the club missed out on a
Champions League place.
Liverpool are £351m in debt and were put up for sale by co-owners
Tom Hicks and George Gillett earlier this year.
The American pair's ownership of the Reds has drawn protests from
Liverpool fans, who are unhappy with the way the club is being run.
Now news of Benitez's impending departure will inevitably lead to
question marks over the futures of several key players.
Captain Steven Gerrard, star forward Fernando Torres and Argentina
midfielder Javier Mascherano have all recently being linked with
summer moves elsewhere.
BBC sports news correspondent Dan Roan said Benitez was "certain to
"The board are in discussions with the manager about him leaving
immediately," said Roan.
"A severance deal has been offered to Benitez and it is worth
significantly more than the £3m that has been reported - he is
entitled to £16m as a result of the contract he signed last year.
"Benitez is currently on holiday but if he decides to accept their
offer he could be out by the weekend."
Benitez's agent, Manuel Garcia Quilon, said he would be speaking to
the former Valencia boss on Thursday, adding: "We don't know
anything more than what's being said. We're not saying anything."
Benitez has been linked to Italian giants Inter Milan, who are
looking for a coach following Jose Mourinho's move to Real Madrid.
Liverpool have refused to comment on the future of their manager.
"The club are concerned that details being leaked out could
undermine the severance deal," added Roan. "Significantly, no
replacement has so far been approached, but that process is sure to
Academy director Kenny Dalglish, who won three league titles as
manager at Anfield between 1985 and 1991, is believed to have been
lined up as an interim replacement.
Fulham manager Roy Hodgson and Aston Villa boss Martin O'Neill have
been mentioned as potential targets to take over in the long-term.
Benitez replaced Gerard Houllier at Anfield in June 2004 and enjoyed
a successful start to his tenure as Liverpool won the Champions
League the following season.
But they could only finish seventh in the Premier League last term
despite finishing as runners-up to Manchester United the previous
As well as the Champions League triumph, Benitez also steered
Liverpool to the European Super Cup in 2005 and the FA Cup in 2006.
But the inconsistency of last season, where they lost 11 times in
the league and exited the Champions League in the group stages,
seems to have been a turning point.
Benitez had suggested he would require in excess of £50m to put the
club back in contention for Champions League qualification, let
alone the Premier League title, while co-owner Hicks recently said
the Spaniard would have a "substantial" transfer budget this summer.
However, Benitez looks destined to leave, despite telling the
Liverpool Echo recently that he wanted to stay at Anfield "for a
Rafa defends record
By Mike Barton - Sky Sports
Rafael Benitez has defended his record since
taking over as Liverpool boss, insisting that his side have
progressed rather than fallen behind.
Benitez has been consistently linked with a move away from
Merseyside, with Inter Milan reportedly lining him up as a
replacement for his old rival Jose Mourinho, who looks likely to
join Real Madrid this summer.
The 50-year-old Spaniard took charge at Anfield in 2004, winning the
UEFA Champions League in his first season and the FA Cup one year
later in what appeared to be the dawn of a successful era for the
However despite reaching another Champions League final in 2007 and
coming close to winning the Premier League last season, this
campaign Liverpool endured a miserable time, finishing seventh in
the league and failing to qualify for Europe's premier competition.
"There is this legend that Liverpool hasn't won many trophies, that
we have failed in that aspect," Benitez told the Daily Mirror.
"Well, Chelsea and Manchester United have won 10 trophies in the six
years I've been in Liverpool; Arsenal, Spurs and Portsmouth one.
"Liverpool? Four trophies and we have played in three finals.
Liverpool have been competitive.
"Does Liverpool have to win the league, as everybody demands, every
The former Valencia boss also went on to state how his spending and
dealing in the transfer market could not compare with the
expenditure of United and Chelsea, who have been by far the most
successful clubs in England since he took charge.
"Does the manager have absolute power in England?" he questioned.
"No, it depends on a budget and on the executive director that
negotiates the signings of players.
"And it depends on the money you have and the intelligence with
which you operate in the market place.
"Look at the wages picked up by the players on Chelsea or Manchester
United's substitutes' bench: (John) Obi Mikel, (Michael) Owen,
(Salomon) Kalou, (Dimitar) Berbatov, (Michael) Carrick could be on
£4million a year!
"When Portsmouth offered Peter Crouch more money than we were paying
him and promised him a starting place, it became very complicated
for us to keep hold of him. The arrival of Fernando Torres meant he
couldn't play as often at Liverpool."
One of the main criticisms levelled at Benitez has been that he has
had money to spend in the transfer market, however he countered this
assumption stating that he had made money for the club rather than
"Some people say I have spent £280million," he added.
"But we have spent £220million on players and generated £160million
in player sales. That is the equivalent of a £60million net spend
over six years: in other words, £10million spent per year.
"Deduct from that figure the £120million revenue from the Champions
League success and qualification over that period, and we have in
fact generated an additional £60million benefits for the club."
Only winning the title can stop
the snipers, says Rafael Benitez
By Ian Doyle - Liverpool Daily Post
Rafael Benitez admits the pressure as Liverpool
manager will only ease once he wins the championship.
Benitez’s Anfield tenure has attracted increasing criticism the
longer he fails to end a title drought that stretches back to 1990.
Having secured runners-up spot 12 months ago, Liverpool last week
concluded a hugely disappointing campaign in which they finished
seventh, their lowest final Premier League placing in more than a
Despite speculation linking him with an imminent departure, Benitez
is keen to stay at Anfield and is awaiting a third meeting with
chairman Martin Broughton to discuss the future direction of the
But the Spaniard concedes he will remain under intense scrutiny
until he claims Liverpool’s 19th championship crown.
“It is impossible to ignore the pressure (of being a manager) until
you have won the league title,” said Benitez.
“You know you have a responsibility, there are demands on you and
you have to get used to it. Every week you have to pass a test.
“As a manager you have to try to be respectful, correct, sometimes
positive, other times not so much.
“A coach has to try to protect his players so that they can express
themselves. When things go badly, it is the manager’s
responsibility. That is normal. It is innate in football.”
Benitez continues to plan for the new season, having already secured
the signature of Charlton Athletic teenager Jonjo Shelvey and
closing in on a deal for highly-rated young Glasgow Rangers
centre-back Danny Wilson.
A free transfer move for Standard Liege striker Milan Jovanovic
remains in the offing, although the Liverpool manager admits
activity has been hampered by the forthcoming World Cup.
“Liverpool are working on our next signings,” said Benitez. “I have
my ideas and I know what I want, but we have to wait, because now we
have the difficulty that the World Cup always brings.”
Benitez aims to land ‘Best of British’
By Dominic King - Liverpool Echo
Rafa today promised Benitez Liverpool will
continue to pursue a “Best of British” transfer policy whenever
possible this summer as they begin the task of rebuilding.
The Reds swooped to sign hot prospect Jonjo Shelvey – who has played
for England at a number of youth levels – last month from Charlton
Athletic in a £1.7m deal.
They are also close to wrapping up an move for Glasgow Rangers
defender Danny Wilson, a move that looks all the more shrewd after
he was named Scotland’s Young Player of the Year.
In the past, Benitez has been criticised for favouring the foreign
transfer market and not giving home-grown players the opportunity to
show they are good enough to play for Liverpool.
Benitez, however, has defended his policy and has made it clear he
would be happy to chase deals for English players – as long as the
right option comes along.
“It is something that we have always tried to do,” he said. “We
tried to sign Gareth Barry, we did the same with (Glen) Johnson.
That was always the idea.
“We have tried to bring in British players with the right mentality
and the passion for the club.
“We want them to know what it means to play for Liverpool Football
“Shelvey is an addition like that. We are trying to do what is best
for the club. We have a long-term plan in place and we try to follow
Benitez, meanwhile, has not lost faith in Liverpool’s squad and is
confident they will show their true colours next season.
“This team has good players and we have a good team,” adds Benitez.
“We just had too many problems, too many injuries. We also had some
difficulty dealing with expectation that everyone was thinking about
us at the beginning of the season.”
Rafa wants chance
to set record straight
Liverpool manager Rafael Benitez believes he
should be given the time and resources to correct the mistakes of
A goalless draw at Hull just about summed up the Reds’ campaign as
they missed an opportunity to capitalise on Aston Villa’s defeat to
Blackburn and move up a place in the Barclays Premier League table.
The resulting seventh spot represented Liverpool’s worst league
performance since 1999.
Although Benitez has been linked with Juventus and now Inter Milan
the prospects of him leaving Anfield seem to be more remote than
they were a couple of months ago.
The Spaniard stressed in his post-match press conference at the KC
Stadium that he was inclined to stay if the club were able to meet
If Liverpool wanted to sack their manager, who has four years
remaining on a lucrative contract signed only 14 months ago, it
would most likely cost them somewhere between £12m and £16m (€14m
And with their current financial difficulties – figures relating to
last season published a few days ago showed the debt of Liverpool’s
parent company Kop Holdings had risen to £351m (€408m) – that would
be a major undertaking.
Benitez is set to meet chairman Martin Broughton, appointed last
month by co-owners Tom Hicks and George Gillett to oversee the sale
of the club, for a second time this week.
It is anticipated the pair will try to find some common ground on
how to take the club forward, which the manager appears keen to do
providing further barriers are not put in his way.
“For any manager, when you have a bad season, you want to improve
and change things and I think it has to be this way,” said Benitez,
who has now gone four years without a trophy having won the
Champions League and the FA Cup in his first two years in charge.
“I think all the managers, especially when they are in England and
are at a club for a long time, will have good moments and bad
“In football every year you cannot win and win and win. You can see
Chelsea winning (the Premier League), not winning and now winning
again so it can happen.”
Asked if he deserved another chance after such a dismal season,
Benitez added: “It depends. ’Senior sources’ maybe will say
different but it has been the same in the history of football.”
The mention of ’senior sources’ is in reference to Benitez’s belief
that a campaign is being waged against him in the media. In his
post-match comments he used the phrase half a dozen times in
relation to reports which claimed he was prepared to sell captain
Steven Gerrard and striker Fernando Torres – a suggestion he
dismissed out of hand.
But until he can come up with an agreeable plan for the future with
Broughton nothing can be seen as definite.
“Every meeting helps, in one way or another, and at this moment we
have to talk about everything,” said the Reds boss.
“Hopefully the second meeting will be as positive as the first
one...but the press continue with the same agenda.
“I think for the stability of the club it is important because we
have to move forward on everything.
“Hopefully we can progress with our next meeting.”
Torres will not be sold
By Dominic King - Liverpool Echo
Liverpool chairman Martin Broughton has promised
supporters that neither Steven Gerrard or Fernando Torres will be
sold to service the club’s debt.
There have been fears for many months that Liverpool’s financial
plight under the current ownership of Tom Hicks and George Gillett
would mean a top name would have to be sacrificed to meet loan
With Christian Purslow having failed to find investment since he was
made managing director, Hicks and Gillett appointed Broughton and
Barclays Capital to unearth an investor who would be willing to buy
Liverpool in its entirety.
Still, however, there are worries that Torres and/or Gerrard could
go after what has been a hugely disappointing season.
“There’s absolutely no reason to sell either Torres or Gerrard,”
“I don’t want to sell either of them; Rafa doesn’t want to sell
either of them.
“The club is not looking to sell either of those. We don’t need to
do it to pay off any debt. I can understand their concern.
“Torres is one of the great players; every club would love to have
him. We have got him and there is no intention of selling him.”
Broughton and Purslow met Rafa Benitez in London on Thursday for a
“full and frank” discussion about Liverpool’s future that the
chairman said was “helpful”.
With Liverpool not scheduling their usual Friday press conference
yesterday ahead of the final game of the season at Hull, Benitez has
yet to speak publicly on the meeting. Broughton, however, has
revealed that he has talked to Benitez about squad strengthening and
“What I have asked from Rafa is what I think any football club board
would ask at the end of the season is an appraisal of each of the
players,” said Broughton.
“Where the weak links are, which players he would prefer to sell if
he had the opportunity, what players positions he needs to fill.
What would be his prime candidates, which are his priorities. I
don’t think we start with how much money do you have.”
Time for Rafa Benitez to tell us
the facts over his future at Liverpool FC
Comment by David Prentice - Liverpool Echo
This newspaper had its issues with Gerard
Houllier. A control freak, supremely sensitive to even the mildest
of criticism – and a man who refused to countenance any suggestion
that he might have got anything wrong . . . ever.
Yet when it came to the crunch, Gerard Houllier accepted that no
individual was bigger than Liverpool Football Club.
He relinquished his management of the club graciously, with enormous
dignity and in a manner which reflected well on all parties.
He even posed for pictures on the Anfield pitch.
It’s a lesson in humility the current Liverpool manager would do
well to heed.
I’m a supporter of Benitez. I believe his departure would harm
Liverpool Football Club. I certainly want him to stay.
But at the moment he’s playing Liverpool Football Club – and its
fans – like a harp.
His agent told us on Monday that his client wanted to stay on as
We are told that Benitez was enjoying a day off.
We’re all entitled to a day away from the pressures of the workplace
– especially someone working in the insanely pressurised environment
of a top Premier League football club.
But this is the man who last summer interrupted a family holiday in
Sardinia to return my call and get the message out that Barcelona
could forget about signing Javier Mascherano.
If Rafa has a point to make, he will make it.
Which is why the silence, or the cryptic ‘concentrating on the next
match messages’ are so disingenuous.
All that’s being gained by maintaining a dignified silence is adding
fuel to those that believe his “pride” at being courted by Juventus
is something more tangible.
If Rafael Benitez wants to stay at Liverpool Football Club, why not
tell us forcefully, unequivocally and clearly?
Then we can turn the spotlight on the men who will make that
decision, content that at least one party inside Anfield is still
doing things the Liverpool Way.
Benitez opens talks on his future
BBC Sport Online
Liverpool have had the first in what they hope
will be a series of meetings with manager Rafael Benitez amid
speculation he could move to Juventus.
Benitez, 50, had reportedly cancelled two meetings with chairman
Martin Broughton before they met on Thursday.
"The meeting was constructive," said a Liverpool spokesman.
"Views were exchanged on issues of concern to both the board and
manager which were either addressed or to be picked up in
Benitez, who has four years left on the contract he signed last
summer, has endured a tough season on and off the pitch.
In November he said he was sure of guiding Liverpool to a top-four
finish in the Premier League, but last Sunday's 2-0 home defeat by
Chelsea ended the chance of that happening.
As a result, Liverpool will be without Champions League football
next season - the first time since 2002/03.
The Reds made an early exit from both the Champions League and FA
Cup, and their last chance for silverware ended when they lost to
Atletico Madrid in the Europa League semi-final last week.
As well as their on-field struggles, Liverpool's season has been
overshadowed by continued speculation about the future ownership of
the club, which came to a head in April when owners Tom Hicks and
George Gillett said they would be looking to sell.
Smith calls for
Benitez to come clean
Liverpool legend Tommy Smith has labelled the
Reds' current campaign as "the season from hell" and pleaded with
manager Rafael Benitez to clarify his future at the club.
Liverpool are in turmoil both on and off the pitch, having failed to
qualify for the Champions League and with uncertainty regarding the
Anfield outfit's future ownership.
And speculation continues to link Benitez with a move to Juventus at
the end of a season that delivered another hard blow with
Liverpool's elimination from the Europa League in the semi-finals
It has all been too much for Smith, who spoke out in his Liverpool
"Rafa has always said he loves the club, the fans and the city. For
the sake of all three, he must now come out and make his intentions
clear - one way or the other," Smith said.
"Rafa has said nothing publicly to suggest he is still up for the
challenge, ready to try and sort out the problems and go again. That
is only adding to the anxiety and fuelling more controversy.
"We all know the problems the American ownership has brought - and
at times caused the manager. It can't have been easy for him to a
degree but in truth he has made mistakes which cannot be blamed on
(Tom) Hicks and (George) Gillett.
"Not only has this campaign been the season from hell, with 19
defeats, the manager is giving every indication he has had enough
and wants out.
"One word sums up the whole, sorry state of affairs at Liverpool
these days - embarrassing.
"Granted, Rafa's bought some really good players - but others seem
happy to pull on the red shirt yet have no idea what it means to
"This squad isn't good enough and does not have enough depth to it.
That is a crying shame because we've had such a strong spine with
players like (Jose) Reina, (Jamie) Carragher, (Javier) Mascherano,
(Steven) Gerrard and (Fernando) Torres to have built around."
Smith, who made 638 appearances for the club, believes the fans
He added: "These Liverpool supporters are always there through thick
and thin - and right now it is very thin times indeed for them all.
"The manager must first come out and make his intentions clear. Then
we have to pray that soon the club is sold to owners who have the
clout to invest in it and get us back on track.
"For the sake of those wonderful fans, I hope they get some good
news soon. Because they deserve it."
Liverpool FC on its knees
as season ends in strife
Comment by Dominic King - Liverpool Echo
There was a time, not so long ago, when Liverpool
supporters used to ask, then discuss, five straightforward
They went along the following lines: Who are we playing? When and
where is the game? Which players are injured? What are our transfer
It was a simple time. Occasionally results would go askew and that
would lead to some frustration but, in the main, feelings of angst
were always assuaged by the fact the club had firm foundations and
were capable of recovery.
If only the same could be said now. Pre and post match chatter these
days, particularly after Sunday’s harrowing defeat against Chelsea,
is consumed by one alarming quandary – why? Why has it come to this?
The end of the season from hell, which will finish with Liverpool
taking the road to Hull, cannot come quickly enough but when the
final whistle sounds at the KC Stadium on Sunday afternoon, it will
not signal the termination of all woes.
Far from it. Liverpool, as it has been noted on many occasions, is a
club on its knees, lacking direction, the rudderless ship sailing
into the eye of a storm; each passing day brings about a new,
complex set of woes.
Take yesterday’s events. After the agenda had been dominated for
days of how Rafa Benitez wants to meet new chairman Martin
Broughton, a story then appears claiming that Liverpool’s manager
had cancelled two appointments.
At a time when the club needs everyone pulling in the same
direction, to arrest an alarming slide, it is impossible to escape
the conclusion that, unless drastic, decisive action is taken,
Liverpool are on the verge of falling to a place from where there is
Browse any Liverpool supporters’ forum you wish on the internet and
you will see the mood is inescapably dark. Fears are growing that
the travails of the past nine months are a worrying sign of things
Benitez has made it quite clear that he wants reassurances about
Liverpool’s financial climate and, if he is to continue as manager,
that is both reasonable and understandable, given what has happened
during the past two years.
Unable to escape the feeling that his main priority is to juggle the
debt saddled upon it by Tom Hicks and George Gillett, many are
wondering whether he has reached breaking point after becoming
increasingly disillusioned over broken promises.
Examine the case of Milan Jovanovic, for starters. Despite having
worked hard to convince the Serbian international to join on a
Bosman transfer, the pre-contract agreement remains hitherto
“I decided to sign an extension because the squad was good and the
money could be there. At the end, things changed,” Benitez said
after Liverpool’s bid to reach the Europa League final was ended by
“We’ve had a bad season and hopefully things will be different in
the future, but at the moment I can’t talk about the future because
I don’t know what’s going on.”
Nor, it would seem, does anyone else. Though Barclays Capital have
been drafted in to oversee the sale of Liverpool, Hicks and Gillett
– much to the Kop’s increasing chagrin – are not going to riding off
into the sunset any time soon.
Broughton’s arrival has posed questions over the position of
Christian Purslow as managing director; his chief responsibility was
to find fresh investment that would lower the level of debt and give
Liverpool the scope to start work on building that fabled new home
in Stanley Park.
Bar one episode with the New York-based Rhone Group in March, as yet
the club is no closer to receiving the significant cash injection
the squad that is so desperately needed to get Liverpool back on an
Should that not happen, riding off into the sunset could become a
theme for the summer; the future for Fernando Torres, for one, is
far from certain and any number of clubs would be willing to pounce
if he gave an indication that he wants to move. Ditto Steven
Both those men are desperate to win football’s major prizes wearing
Liver Birds on their chest but do you honestly see Liverpool
throwing down a title challenge next season to placate their
frustrations of not being in the Champions League?
Benitez, whose family is settled on Merseyside, wants money to
strengthen his squad but critics – and there are a growing number –
will ask whether he can be trusted to spend it, given that his last
major acquisitions (Glen Johnson/Alberto Aquilani) have failed to
pull up trees.
What’s more, club officials have been unimpressed with the way he
has flirted with Juventus since revealing his “pride” at the initial
link with the Serie A club in January; for many reasons, there are
significant tensions in the corridors of power.
Yet regardless of that, Manuel Garcia Quilon – Benitez’s agent –
said yesterday that his client wants to continue as Liverpool
manager and it must be stressed there is no real appetite among
senior figures to make that change.
So if that is the case, why are the wheels coming off – a point
hammered home by the fact they have suffered 19 defeats this season
– so spectacularly? Why is the club that made conducting business
behind closed doors an art form now showing the world its myriad
Perhaps the situation will become clearer after Benitez and
Broughton eventually speak and, inevitably, there will be a full and
frank exchanging of views – that meeting simply has to find a
resolution to problems that have loitered for years.
If it doesn’t, the simple, straightforward life that every
Liverpudlian craves – you know, the one that sees them talking about
a successful football team – will remain a pipedream and the
questions, sadly, will only become more difficult.
Agent: Rafa wishes to stay with Reds
Rafael Benitez's agent claims the Liverpool boss
has not received any offers from Juventus or any other club - and
wants to stay at Anfield.
Speculation over Benitez's future shows no signs of abating, with
Manuel Garcia Quilon's comments in the last few weeks having ranged
from suggesting Juventus were ready to sign Benitez this summer to
the latest proclamation that he has no intention of leaving Anfield.
Even Benitez himself may not be entirely sure where his future lies
as he waits to hear what chairman Martin Broughton has to say about
plans for next season and beyond.
Crucial to everything remains any proposed takeover after co-owners
Tom Hicks and George Gillett officially put the club up for sale
last month, appointing Broughton to oversee the process.
Having finally scheduled a meeting with the chairman for this week
Benitez will eagerly await the latest update on potential investors
and, more importantly, what his likely summer transfer budget will
Even with the £6million generated from the January sales of Andriy
Voronin and Andrea Dossena and money from the expected summer
departures of a few first-team fringe players the Liverpool manager
will still be looking for a figure around the £40million mark.
If there are no indications he is likely to get anything close to
that sum Benitez then has a decision to make, although his options
have been complicated by the fact that long-time suitors Juventus
have, like Liverpool, failed to qualify for the Champions League.
And despite their very public courting of Benitez in recent months,
Quilon denied the Serie A side had made an official approach.
"We have not received any offers from any club," Quilon told Press
Association Sport. "Benitez's aim is to remain at Liverpool and try
to help the team improve with new owners.
"He is under contract and his wish is to remain at Liverpool."
Quilon's denial of any interest has not prevented Juve goalkeeper
Gianluigi Buffon from praising Benitez's qualities.
"Rafa's CV is really good. Tactically he is a very good manager but
he has also showed he can deal with problems off the pitch," said
the Italy international.
"Benitez is a great professional that every team would like to
If new owners are found, and there is little likelihood of any
development on that score before the end of the month, they may
decide Benitez's future for him.
The former Valencia coach has four years remaining on his long-term
contract and would be entitled to around £12million compensation
were he to be sacked.
Hicks and Gillett are unlikely to sanction such a payment as they
are looking to maximise their return having bought the club back in
But a new investor may have their own ideas about who they want to
lead the club forward.
now Rafa, holding your head high
By Henry Winter - Irish Independent
If Rafael Benitez truly respects Liverpool
Football Club he'll leave Anfield today. The players have lost the
faith, the boardroom is unimpressed with the politicking and the
supporters are suffering, albeit in silence.
If Benitez exits quickly, accepting Juventus' generous offer, he
goes with some dignity. If he stays, the inevitable long goodbye
becomes indescribably messy, distressing for all concerned and
demeaning to a club of Liverpool's great history. This is not a
warning for Benitez, this is a fact.
He's lucky. The Kop's refusal to call for his head, in the wake of a
disastrous season and four trophy-less years, speaks handsomely of
their substance and loyalty. At any other major club, probably
barring Arsenal, restless natives would have been chanting for the
Benitez now meets Liverpool's new chairman, Martin Broughton, to
discuss transfer budgets but why should the board trust him with the
His record is too inconsistent. They give him money for a table and
he comes back with a lampshade. He's got a centre-back at left-back
and a holding midfielder at right-back. Liverpool's squad is an
exercise in mismanagement.
Over the past six years, Benitez has been provided with
£230,476,000, not forgetting a rich bequest in Steven Gerrard and
Jamie Carragher, yet his bench against Atletico Madrid last Thursday
read: Diego Cavalieri, Sotirios Kyrgiakos, David Ngog, Philipp
Degen, Nabil El Zhar, Daniel Ayala and Daniel Pacheco. Their entries
in football's Who's Who do not run to many lines. Combined.
How embarrassing. This is Liverpool, five-times winners of the
European Cup and joint record-holders of 18 league championships,
the club of Bill Shankly and Bob Paisley, John Toshack and Kevin
Keegan, Kenny Dalglish and Graeme Souness, Robbie Fowler and Michael
Owen, yet with largely a bunch of unknowns on the bench. How the
mighty are fallen.
Benitez's cheerleaders claim his achievements at Anfield are
actually remarkable given his restricted budget over the past two
seasons. They point to injuries and mention the more alluring wages
on offer elsewhere. Good try. Roy Hodgson prospers at Fulham on a
fraction of Benitez's resources and none of the annoying scheming.
Arsene Wenger spends far less than Benitez and has a far better eye
for young talent.
Any inspection of Benitez's £230m outlay must highlight successes
such as Pepe Reina, Javier Mascherano and Fernando Torres. Not all
were guaranteed to do well yet they have grown under Benitez. Even
with Lucas, Kyrgiakos, Ryan Babel and Emiliano Insua on the books,
Liverpool's squad are valued at around £250m.
Yet Liverpool's board could legitimately ask Benitez his views on
Hodgson's team-building skills and just who is that leading Fulham
out in the Europa League final in Hamburg next week? Why it's Danny
Murphy, just the type of strong character and intelligent midfielder
Liverpool crave, a popular player shown the door by Benitez in the
first of his summer clear-outs/trolley dashes. Murphy or Lucas?
Discuss. But not for long.
All managers sell players they shouldn't but Benitez has dropped
some real clangers. How Liverpool could do with a committed
left-back like Stephen Warnock, whose heart was almost broken when
let go by Benitez.
Warnock, now knocking on England's door, could have spared Liverpool
those awkward moments when Andrea Dossena or Insua was at left-back.
Dear old Dossena. Recruited for £7m in July 2008, he endured a
hapless stay, being humiliated by Leeds United's Robert Snodgrass
among others, and was offloaded for £4.3m to Napoli 18 months later.
Dossena's fellow recruits in the class of 2008 were Cavalieri, Ngog,
Robbie Keane and Albert Riera at a cost of £39m, and none proved
Quantity as much as quality has been Benitez's hallmark in the
He has brought in 77 players, a tally that prompted Ian St John to
remark wryly over the weekend that "maybe Rafa's setting up his own
Whatever happened to Benitez's likely lads such as Miki Roque,
Krisztian Nemeth, Astrit Ajdarevic, Antonio Barragan, Besian Idriza,
Mikel San Jose Dominguez and Antonio Nunez?
The haemorrhaging of money on fees, let alone wages, is a concern.
Jermaine Pennant arrived for £6.7m and went on a free. Fernando
Morientes cost £6.3m and exited for £3m.
Keane hardly had time to unpack his bags after his £19m signing
before being shipped out for £16m, lacking suitability to the
manager's new 4-2-3-1 system.
Benitez has been given enough money. He's just not given his buying
enough thought. Time to go. If anyone can fix Benitez up with
flights to Turin it's Broughton.
Thor Zakariassen ©